Legacy Matters
The newsletters are available in full below
Legacy Matters Part 1
Legacy Matters Part 2
Legacy Matters Part 2
Editorial
Padraig Yeates & Andy Pollack
Legacy Matters attempts to address one of the most pressing challenges posed by the Troubles for our society, and particularly for individuals and families directly affected by the conflict over 25 years after the Belfast Good Friday Agreement was made.
Equity, Mercy, Forgiveness: Interpreting Amnesty within the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission
Wilhelm Verwoerd
In July 1997, during the first day of their amnesty hearing, my initial anger at seeing the applicants in person unexpectedly gave way to more mixed feelings of empathy and deep sadness
Wilhelm Verwoerd, past crimes and amnesties
Brice Dickenson
Wilhelm Verwoerd’s article on why he approved of the amnesty provisions in South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s process is fascinating.
Time out of mind: A response to Wilhelm Verwoerd
Cillian McGrattan
If things have happened in the past which have been disturbing, then how does the individual concerned deal with them?
Gender, Truth and Legacy
Fidelma Ashe
All official attempts at dealing with the past in Northern Ireland have marginalised gender issues. The occlusion of gender from processes designed to address the legacies of the region’s conflict is a direct consequence of how peace and conflict have been framed.
I couldn’t see for lookin’
Eamon Baker
Back in the summer of 1971, when the Troubles were being ratcheted up, with riots, shootings and bombings becoming commonplace, and even with 75 people having already been killed, I was still in many ways a twenty year old 'innocent abroad'
The Truth about the Troubles
Ian McBride
Northern Ireland is a small region, comparable in size to Yorkshire or Connecticut, and with just 1.8 million inhabitants. But for scholars and students interested in the burgeoning field of memory studies it presents a vast academic safari park.
A Case Study of Mistaken Identity - featuring ‘John Wayne’ and ‘Comanche’
James Kinchin White
At around a quarter to eight on the morning of 15 April 1972, John and Gerard Conway were, as usual on a Saturday morning, walking along Whiterock Road to catch a bus to McQuillan Street on the Falls Road, where they had a fruit and vegetable stall. Within an hour, both brothers would be in the Royal Victoria Hospital with gunshot wounds.
Paramilitary Terror and Human Rights Violations
Liam Kennedy
The agonising wait by a hospital bed for the family of Detective Chief Inspector John Caldwell of the PSNI continues. An easy target for dissident republicans, he was shot multiple times after a children’s football training session near Omagh.
What would be an appropriate Memorial Archive?
Kathryn Johnson
The question of building a memorial to victims of the Troubles which is acceptable to all sections of the community here is problematic. There is dissent from some on the definition of victims.
Brian Maguire - Artist
Brian Maguire (72) is an artist based in Dublin and Paris. He is represented by the Kerlin Gallery (Dublin) and the Christophe Gaillard Gallerie (Paris).
Legacy Matters Part 1
Editorial
Padraig Yeates & Andy Pollack
Legacy Matters attempts to address one of the most pressing challenges posed by the Troubles for our society, and particularly for individuals and families directly affected by the conflict over 23 years after the Belfast Good Friday Agreement was made.
Alleviating the Harms of the Troubles
Brice Dickson
I believe that the European Court would tolerate a ban on prosecutions if it was issued as part of a fulsome truth and reconciliation process. The Court’s case law is sparse on what steps can lawfully be taken to alter a criminal justice system as part of a transitional justice process, but it already accepts that states have a discretion to limit prosecutions, even for murder, if a lengthy period has elapsed since the commission of the crime.
The Politics of Apology and the Legacies of Conflict in Northern Ireland: Help or Hindrance?
Stephen Hopkins
The politics of apology are taking place in an ostensibly ‘post-conflict’ environment, but one in which the claims of victims and survivors of violence for judicial prosecutions and punishments for perpetrators are highly unlikely to be met.
An Idea So Controversial The Discussion Has Mostly Been In Private
Brendan Keenan
It is a long way from an amnesty for those seeking reconciliation, even redemption, to freedom from prosecution for everyone, whatever their actions and attitudes. I fully understand why, if a Truth Recovery Process was discussed, it would be rejected. The unfortunate thing is that the idea is so controversial that discussion has mostly been in private.
Some Childhood Memories Of Life In Turf Lodge
Forgotten Victims Of The Troubles
Liam Kennedy
Commissions of inquiry, North and South, have opened up the secret world of abuse in baby and child homes, industrial schools and reformatories within Irish society. A commission of enquiry that engages with those brutalised and tortured by loyalist and republican paramilitaries is long overdue.
Legacy Matters
Alan McBride
If ‘reconciliation matters’ then ‘Legacy Matters’…. You cannot engage in a process of reconciliation whilst leaving the past untreated like a weeping wound that has formed a scab.
Legacy And Oral History
Claire Hackett
Far from being an alternative, oral history narratives make clear why there needs to be a comprehensive and integrated approach to dealing with the past.
History And Remembering - Voices From The Past
Sam White
If things have happened in the past which have been disturbing, then how does the individual concerned deal with them?
Some Childhood Memories Of Life In Turf Lodge
Aine McCann
The soldier standing on the back of the jeep began to fire at the shops. We all ran. Someone held the door open for me as I ran with the pram into the bakery and over to the far corner and pulled the baby from the pram. We all lay on the floor.
‘The Past Is Not Dead. It’s Not Even Past’
Liz McManus
With the passing of time the chances of a successful recourse to the judicial process are fading but the pain and frustration of those who have been hurt does not fade. There is an onus on us all to find another route to the truth.
Why The Protagonists Write Literature and Legacy In Northern Ireland
Connal Parr
Loyalists in working-class communities … are still being led into the future of the mis-remembered past, which is not theirs and holds little for them beyond criminal convictions and stale cycles of violence.
Dealing With The Legacy Of The Past
The Pat Finucane Centre/Justice for the Forgotten
We accept, as you propose in your Truth Recovery Process, that there may be an argument for a form of limited immunity from prosecution, provided there is a parallel process of fully-resourced, robust, Article 2 compliant investigations in which bereaved families can have confidence
I Never Felt So Proud And Fulfilled By A Job: A British Solider’s Recollections Of His First Tour In Northern Ireland
James Kinchin White
I feel we could, collectively, have done much more, much better and maybe have prevented some of the pain. That’s my legacy and it's my driving force to combine knowledge gained as a ‘participant’ with subsequently acquired skills to try to make a contribution to our understanding what happened, how it evolved and why?
Between History And Memory: The Politics Of Truth Recovery and The Limits Of Ethical Remembering
Cillian McGrattan
Although the truth recovery model enjoys a distinguished, yet, with at best, an empirically and heuristically questionable, lineage, its promotion within elements of the Irish political classes is structurally biased in favour of nationalist ideological goals.